First Things First - Religious Freedom & Who Influenced Jefferson's Views on Separation of Church & State - American Minute with Bill Federer

First Things First: Religious Freedom! Who influenced Jefferson's views on Separation of Church & State - American Minute with Bill Federer

On JANUARY 1, 1802, the people of Cheshire, Massachusetts, delivered a giant block of cheese weighing 1,235 lbs to President Thomas Jefferson, being presented by the famous Baptist preacher, John Leland.

On the block of cheese, they put Jefferson's motto, which was also on his personal seal: "Rebellion to Tyrants is Obedience to God."
After delivering the cheese, John Leland was then invited to preach to the President and Congress in the U.S. Capitol.
The subject of his talk was "separation of church and state."
Baptists had been particularly persecuted in colonial Virginia, as Francis L. Hawks wrote in Ecclesiastical History (1836):
"No dissenters in Virginia experienced for a time harsher treatment than the Baptists ...
... They were beaten and imprisoned ...
Cruelty taxed ingenuity to devise new modes of punishment and annoyance."
So many Baptist ministers were harassed, and their church services disrupted, that James Madison introduced legislation in Virginia's Legislature on October 31, 1785, titled "A Bill for Punishing Disturbers of Religious Worship," which passed in 1789.
Colonial Virginia had a government imposed belief system, an "establishment" of the Church of England, or "Anglican Church" from 1606 to 1786.
Establishment meant:
  • mandatory membership;
  • mandatory taxes to support it; and
  • no one could hold public office unless they were a member.
This was modeled after European nations who had establishments of different Christian denominations.
History records how oppressive governments are tempted to establish government mandated belief systems, from King Nebuchadnezzar (Daniel 3), to Islamists, fundamental Hindus, atheistic socialists, enforcement of LGBTQ Trans beliefs, and untested healthcare practices.
In Virginia, lax enforcement allowed immigration of "dissenting" religious groups, the first being Presbyterians and Quakers, followed by German Lutherans, Mennonites and Moravian Brethren, then finally Baptists.
Patrick Henry almost succeeded in having Virginia not ratify the Constitution as it did not have a Bill of Rights guaranteeing, among other things, the freedom of religion.
Baptist Preacher John Leland had considered running for Congress, as he wanted an Amendment added to the new United States Constitution which would protect religious liberty.
Leland reportedly met with James Madison near Orange, Virginia.
Upon Madison's promise to introduce what would become the First Amendment, Leland agreed to persuade Baptists to get involved in politics and support Madison.
John Leland wrote in Rights of Conscience Inalienable, 1791, that they wanted not just toleration, but equality:
"Every man must give account of himself to God, and therefore every man ought to be at liberty to serve God in a way that he can best reconcile to his conscience.
If government can answer for individuals at the day of judgment, let men be controlled by it in religious matters; otherwise, let men be free."
John Leland was following in the tradition of the Baptist Roger Williams, who fled England to Massachusetts, then fled to found Rhode Island.
The situation was that Puritans were persecuted by the established Anglican Church in England.
They fled in a Great Puritan Migration to Massachusetts, where they proceeded to establish Puritanism.
Supreme Court Justice Hugo Lafayette Black wrote in Engel v. Vitale, 1962:
"When some of the very groups which had most strenuously opposed the established Church of England found themselves sufficiently in control of colonial governments in this country to write their own prayers into law, they passed laws making their own religion the official religion of their respective colonies."
Roger Williams wrote in his Plea for Religious Liberty, 1644:
"The doctrine of persecution for cause of conscience is most contrary to the doctrine of Christ Jesus the Prince of Peace ...
God requireth not a uniformity of religion to be enacted and enforced in any civil state;
which enforced uniformity (sooner or later) is the greatest occasion of civil war, ravishing of conscience, persecution of Christ Jesus in his servants, and of the hypocrisy and destruction of millions of souls."
A few years later, Quaker founder of Pennsylvania William Penn wrote in England's Present Interest Considered, 1675:
"Force makes hypocrites, 'tis persuasion only that makes converts."
Freedom of conscience gave birth to public evangelistic meetings.
It is rooted in the belief that God loves us and our response is to love Him back, but love, by definition must be voluntary.
Following George Whitefield's First Great Awakening Revival, 1730-1755, a Second Great Awakening Revival took place between 1790-1840.
In Thomas Jefferson's county of Albemarle, Baptist, Presbyterian and Methodist revival meetings were held.
Even Jefferson's daughter, Mary, attended a Baptist revival preached by Lorenzo Dow.
On July 4, 1826, the editor of the Christian Watchman (Boston, MA) published an account:
"ANDREW TRIBBLE was the Pastor of a small Baptist Church, which held its monthly meetings at a short distance from Mr. JEFFERSON'S house, eight or ten years before the American Revolution.
... Mr. JEFFERSON attended the meetings of the church for several months in succession, and after one of them, asked Elder TRIBBLE to go home and dine with him, with which he complied.
Mr. TRIBBLE asked Mr. JEFFERSON how he was pleased with their Church Government?
Mr. JEFFERSON replied, that it had struck him with great force, and had interested him much; that he considered it the only form of pure democracy that then existed in the world, and had concluded that it would be the best plan of Government for the American Colonies."
Thomas F. Curtis wrote in The Progress of Baptist Principles in the Last Hundred Years (Charleston, S.C.: Southern Baptist Publication Society, 1856):
"A gentleman ... in North Carolina ... knowing that the venerable Mrs. (Dolley) Madison had some recollections on the subject, asked her in regard to them.
She expressed a distinct remembrance of Mr. Jefferson speaking on the subject, and always declaring that it was a Baptist church from which these views were gathered."
President Calvin Coolidge stated at the 150th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, July 4, 1926:
"This preaching reached the neighborhood of Thomas Jefferson, who acknowledged that his 'best ideas of democracy' had been secured at church meetings."
During the Revolution, Anglican ministers had sided with King George III, who was head of the Anglican Church.
As a result, patriotic parishioners gained courage to migrate out of the "established" churches and filter into "dissenting" churches.
Jefferson was baptized, married and buried in the Anglican Church, which was called "Episcopal" after America's Revolution, as recorded in his family Bible.
In 1777, though, he started a dissenting church named the Calvinistical Reformed Church.
Jefferson drew up the bylaws of the church, which met in the Albemarle County Courthouse.
His idea was for it to be a "voluntary" church, supported only by the voluntary donations of those who attended.
This contrasted with the Anglican model of church support where citizen paid mandatory taxes to the government, which in turn dispensed funds to established churches.
Jefferson's memorandum book showed he contributed to the evangelical pastor of the Calvinistical Reformed Church, the Rev. Charles Clay.
Jefferson also gave generously to missionaries and various other churches:
"I have subscribed to the building of an Episcopal church, two hundred dollars, a Presbyterian, sixty dollars, and a Baptist, twenty-five dollars."
After the Revolution, the Virginia legislature rewrote its laws, removing all references to the King.
"Dissenting" churches lobbied Jefferson to take this opportunity to "disestablish" the Anglican Church.
Jefferson responded by writing his Bill for Establishing Religious Freedom.
In 1779, fellow member of Jefferson's Calvinistical Reformed Church, Col. John Harvie, introduced the bill in Virginia's Assembly.
It took seven years to pass.
Justice Hugo Black wrote in Engel v. Vitale, 1962:
"But the successful Revolution against English political domination was shortly followed by intense opposition to the practice of establishing religion by law.
This opposition crystallized rapidly into an effective political force in Virginia where the minority religious groups such as Presbyterians, Lutherans, Quakers and Baptists had gained such strength that the adherents to the established Episcopal Church were actually a minority themselves.
In 1785-1786, those opposed to the established Church ... obtained the enactment of the famous 'Virginia Bill for Religious Liberty' by which all religious groups were placed on an equal footing."
After three of Jefferson's children died, his wife, Martha, died in 1782.
After her funeral, Jefferson suffered depression and withdrew from politics.
In his grief, he burned every letter he had with his wife and sequestered himself in his room for three weeks, only venturing out to ride horseback through the hills of his estate.
Jefferson's daughter, Martha 'Patsy' Jefferson, described how he wept for hours:
"In those melancholy rambles I was his constant companion ... a solitary witness to many a violent burst of grief ... the violence of his emotion ... to this day I do not describe to myself."
Trying to help, Congress asked Jefferson in 1784 to be the U.S. ambassador to France.
France was going through a period of "French infidelity" prior to its bloody French Revolution and Reign of Terror.
Upon returning to America, Jefferson entertained liberal "deist-Christian" ideas, though in later life he was described simply as a "liberal Episcopalian."
Jefferson's bill, with the help of James Madison, finally passed by Virginia's Assembly, January 16, 1786.
So significant was this, that Jefferson noted it on his gravestone as "The Statute of Virginia for Religious Freedom."
It stated:
"Almighty God hath created the mind free ...
All attempts to influence it by temporal punishments ... are a departure from the plan of the Holy Author of religion,
who being Lord both of body and mind, yet chose not to propagate it by coercions on either, as was in His Almighty power to do ...
To compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions, which he disbelieves is sinful and tyrannical ...
Be it enacted ... that no man shall ... suffer on account of his religious opinions."
This last paragraph, if applied today, would mean that Jefferson would have opposed Christian parents having to pay taxes to have their children indoctrinated in public schools with anti-biblical views on sex and marriage.
Jefferson acquired a Qur'an in 1765, but after studying it, he only had praise for the morality of Jesus, as he wrote to William Canby, September 18, 1813:
"Of all the systems of morality, ancient or modern, which have come under my observation, none appear to me so pure as that of Jesus."
Jefferson wrote to Jared Sparks, November 4, 1820:
"I hold the precepts of Jesus as delivered by Himself, to be the most pure, benevolent and sublime which have ever been preached to man."
Jefferson wrote to Joseph Priestly, April 9, 1803, regarding Jesus:
"His system of morality was the most benevolent and sublime probably that has been ever taught, and consequently more perfect than those of any of the ancient philosophers."
Jefferson's belief that "the Holy Author of religion ... chose not to propagate it by coercions" is consistent with an account in the Gospel of John:
"Many of his disciples ... said, 'This is a hard saying; who can hear it?'
When Jesus knew in himself that his disciples murmured at it, he said unto them, 'Doth this offend you?'...
From that time many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him. Then said Jesus unto the twelve, 'Will ye also go away?'
Then Simon Peter answered him, 'Lord, to whom shall we go? thou hast the words of eternal life.'"
Jesus' example of being willing to let disbelievers voluntarily depart is in stark contrast with the coercion present in Islamic "ridda" apostasy laws, where Mohammed said:
"Whoever changes his Islamic religion, kill him." (Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, No. 57)
Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari, narrated by Abdullah:
"Allah's Apostle said, 'The blood of a Muslim ... cannot be shed except ... in three cases ... the one who reverts from Islam (apostate) and leaves the Muslims.'" (Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, Book 83, No. 17)
Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari, narrated by Ikrima, stated:
"Ali burnt some people (hypocrites) ... No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.'" (Hadith Sahih Bukhari, Vol. 4:260, Vol. 9, Book 84, No. 57)
Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari stated:
"The punishment for apostasy (riddah) is well-known in Islamic Sharee'ah. The one who leaves Islam will be asked to repent by the Sharee'ah judge in an Islamic country;
if he does not repent and come back to the true religion, he will be killed as a kafir and apostate, because of the command of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him): 'Whoever changes his religion, kill him.'" (Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari, 3017)
Baptist founder of Rhode Island, Roger Williams, wrote:
"That religion cannot be true which needs such instruments of violence to uphold it."
Jefferson's efforts to disestablish the Anglican Church in Virginia would never have passed had it not been for Methodist Bishop Francis Asbury splitting the popular Methodist movement away from the Anglican Church into its own denomination in 1785, forming the Methodist Episcopal Church.
Francis Asbury also ordained Richard Allen as the first black deacon, and preached the dedication service at Allen's "Mother Bethel" African Methodist Episcopal Church in 1794.
Virginia had notable leaders who resisted "disestablishing" the Anglican, or as it was now called, the Episcopal Church, such as Governor Patrick Henry.
This movement was later termed "anti-disestablishmentarianism," which for decades was the longest word in the English Language.
Virginia built its first Jewish Synagogue, Kahal Kadosh Beth Shalome, in 1789.
Virginia built its first Catholic Church, St. Mary Church, in Alexandria in 1795.
John Leland then helped start Baptist churches in Connecticut -- which was a State having the Congregational Church established from its founding in 1639 until 1818.
Baptists in Connecticut formed the Danbury Baptist Association which sent a letter to President Jefferson, October 7, 1801:
"Sir ... Our Sentiments are uniformly on the side of Religious Liberty
--That Religion is at all times and places a Matter between God and Individuals
--That no man ought to suffer in Name, person or effects on account of his religious Opinions
--That the legitimate Power of civil Government extends no further than to punish the man who works ill to his neighbor:
... But Sir ... our ancient (Connecticut) charter, together with the Laws made coincident therewith ... are; that ... what religious privileges we enjoy (as Baptists) ... we enjoy as favors granted, and not as inalienable rights ...
Sir, we are sensible that the President of the united States IS NOT the national Legislator
& also sensible that the national government CANNOT destroy the Laws of each State;
but our hopes are strong that the sentiments of our beloved President, which have had such genial Effect already, like the radiant beams of the Sun, will shine & prevail through all these States and all the world till Hierarchy and Tyranny be destroyed from the Earth."
In other words, Baptists hoped that Jefferson's sentiments which helped disestablish the Anglican Church in Virginia might also help disestablish the Congregational Church in Connecticut, and likewise influence all other States.
The Danbury Baptist letter to Jefferson continued:
"Sir ... we have reason to believe that America's God has raised you up to fill the chair of State ... May God strengthen you for the arduous task which Providence & the voice of the people have called you ...
And may the Lord preserve you safe from every evil and bring you at last to His Heavenly Kingdom through Jesus Christ our Glorious Mediator."
Jefferson replied with his famous letter, January 1, 1802, agreeing with the Danbury's Baptists, even repeating sections of their letter almost verbatim:
"Gentlemen ... Believing WITH YOU
--that religion is a matter which lies solely between man and his God,
--that he owes account to none other for faith or his worship,
--that the legislative powers of government reach actions only, and not opinions,
I contemplate with solemn reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should 'make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,'
thus building a wall of separation between Church and State ..."
Jefferson ended:
"Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience,
I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore man to all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties.
I reciprocate your kind prayers for the protection and blessing of the common Father and Creator of man."
Baptists were familiar with Jefferson's metaphor "wall of separation," as the Baptist founder of Rhode Island, Roger Williams, used it in his Bloody Tenet of Persecution for Conscience Sake, 1644:
"Jews under the Old Testament ... and ... Christians under the New Testament ... were both separate from the world;
and that when they have opened a gap in the hedge, or wall of separation, between the garden of the Church and the wilderness of the world, God hath ever broken down the wall itself ...
And that therefore if He will ever please to restore His garden and paradise again, it must of necessity be walled in peculiarly unto Himself from the world."
Jefferson viewed the "wall" as limiting the federal government from "inter-meddling" in church government, as explained in his letter to Samuel Miller, January 23, 1808:
"I consider the government of the United States as interdicted (prohibited) by the Constitution from inter-meddling with religious institutions, their doctrines, discipline, or exercises.
This results not only from the provision that no law shall be made respecting the establishment or free exercise of religion, but from that also which reserves to the states the powers not delegated to the United States (10th Amendment) ..."
Jefferson continued:
"Certainly no power to prescribe any religious exercise, or to assume authority in religious discipline, has been delegated to the General (Federal) government ...
Every religious society has a right to determine for itself the times for these exercises, and the objects proper for them, according to their own particular tenets."
Though Jefferson considered the Federal Government limited from "inter-meddling" with what was under States' jurisdiction, it was not limited from spreading religion in Federal territories, as on April 26, 1802, Jefferson's administration extended a 1787 act of Congress where lands were designated:
"For the sole use of Christian Indians and the Moravian Brethren missionaries for civilizing the Indians and promoting Christianity."
And again, December 3, 1803, during Jefferson's administration, Congress ratified a treaty with the Kaskaskia Indians:
"Whereas the greater part of the said tribe have been baptized and received into the Catholic Church ... the United States will give annually, for seven years, one hundred dollars toward the support of a priest of that religion, who will engage to perform for said tribe the duties of his office, and also to instruct as many of their children as possible ...
And the United States will further give the sum of three hundred dollars, to assist the said tribe in the erection of a church."
When Abigail Adams died, Thomas Jefferson wrote to her husband, John Adams, November 13, 1818:
"The term is not very distant, at which we are to deposit in the same cerement, our sorrows and suffering bodies, and to ascend in essence to an ecstatic meeting with the friends we have loved and lost, and whom we shall still love and never lose again.
God bless you and support you under your heavy affliction."
Twelve years before his death, Jefferson shared his personal views to Miles King, September 26, 1814:
"We have heard it said that there is not a Quaker or a Baptist, a Presbyterian or an Episcopalian, a Catholic or a Protestant in heaven; that on entering that gate, we leave those badges of schism behind ...
Let us be happy in the hope that by these different paths we shall all meet in the end. And that you and I may meet and embrace, is my earnest prayer."
Jefferson's religious views went through four periods:
  • faithful Anglican prior to the Revolution, as one could not even hold office in colonial Virginia unless one took the Oath of Supremacy;
  • friend of the dissenters during the Revolution, championing the cause of Baptists and other non-conformists;
  • friend of deists after his wife died prior to the French Revolution, corresponding with Dr. Joseph Priestly;
  • liberal Episcopalian during his term as President, having his administration support Christian missionaries among the Indians and espousing the superior ethics of Jesus.
In a sense, one can have Jefferson say whatever one wants, just pick which period of his life to quote from.
Consistent throughout his life, though, Jefferson believed that there was a Creator and that the government should never force one's conscience.
Over time, brilliant legal minds have used Jefferson's words to prohibit Jefferson's beliefs.
Jefferson believed in a Creator, as he wrote in the Declaration:
"All men are endowed by their CREATOR,"
yet in 2005, U.S. District Judge John E. Jones, in Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District, ruled students could not be taught of a CREATOR: "to preserve the separation of church and state."
In other words, activist judges have used Jefferson's phrase "separation of church and state" out of context to remove national acknowledgments of God, despite Jefferson's specific warning not to do that.
Inscribed on the Jefferson Memorial, Washington, DC is Jefferson's warning:
"God who gave us life gave us liberty. Can the liberties of a nation be secure when we have removed a conviction that these liberties are the gift of God?
Indeed I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just, that His justice cannot sleep forever."
American Minute is a registered trademark of William J. Federer. Permission granted to forward, reprint, or duplicate.
Image Credits: Public Domain, Thomas Jefferson; Artist Rembrandt Peale  (1778–1860); painting /portrait of Thomas Jefferson, third President of the United States, 1801, Collection: White House, Accession number 1962.395.1 (White House), References Google Arts & Culture asset ID: mAHX2Ukt6ZU0KA  Source/Photographer

Older Post Newer Post

  • Barbara Tonkovich on

    This will help me with countering a school board meeting “bully” telling me that I should not read from the Bible during the public 3 minutes call to comment, because of the “separation” which she doesn’t understand because of her attack; pray for me that God will guide my words in meekness and love with the Truth this next April meeting.

  • Bill Coffman on

    Excellent and Outstanding review of some i knew…..much I did not…..Thank You…..

  • Leo Anthony Geis on

    One of your very best posts, and a welcome treat on New Year’s Day (2023). I have an authentic front page from the Philadelphia Public Ledger from August 12, 1843, with a prominent article on the first prayer in Congress (Carpenter’s Hall). My attorney has advised me that it’s not an issue to copy it, but I have it mounted in a very high grade (archival) display case and it would be quite a chore to get it out. If I can get around to copying it I’ll send you a copy.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published